Decision – Miss.S.Ct. – Feb. 18, 2016

Thomas Tubbs v. Statemolestation –  Tubbs was accused of having molested a three-year- old girl that he and his wife were babysitting in December  2009.  Once at home, the child told her mother that Thomas had licked her and pointed to her private parts.  Tubbs told an investigator that he had  spanked the girl.  He told someone else that she  was doing flips in the bed and “flipped right in my face.”  The state was allowed to introduce  Tubbs’s prior conviction for rape of a ten-year-old child was admitted for the limited purpose of proving motive, intent, or absence of mistake or accident.  Tubbs was found guilty and given a 15 year sentence.  On appeal he argues that it was error to let the child testify, to admit her out-of-court statements and to error to admit evidence of dna testing when there was a break in the chain of custody in the handling of the evidence taken from the child’s underpants.

The Court affirms finding that the kid was unusually bright, her out-of-court statements were accompanied by indicia of reliability, and  the state has never been required to produce everyone who handled the evidence.  “The test of whether there has been a break in the chain of custody is ‘whether there is an indication or reasonable inference of probable tampering with the evidence or substitution of the evidence.’”



5 thoughts on “Decision – Miss.S.Ct. – Feb. 18, 2016

  1. Also, two court reporters for Judge Walls ordered to show cause, I guess for failing to complete transcripts in a timely manner?

  2. And Judge Jim Kitchens sentenced Julian Mingo to thirty-years for allegedly “rubbing a sixteen-year old male student through his pants.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s